Walter Rausch’s Field Numbers: Trichocereus, Lobivia and Changing Identifications, 1978–1989

On his first journey to South America, a fellow railway passenger advised Walter Rausch to catch the next train home. He carried on. The Austrian cactus collector and author (1928-2022) went on to make ten journeys to South America, spending more than five years in Argentina and Bolivia and covering over 10,000 kilometres on foot. These are Rausch’s own figures, given in Lobivia 85. His books also reflect years spent comparing cultivated plants and their seeds.

Rausch’s R and WR field numbers still appear on cactus labels and seed packets, attached to plants known as Trichocereus, Lobivia or Echinopsis. A number can lead back to a recorded collection and an earlier identification, even when the name on a nursery label has changed. That makes it worth keeping.

Two entries show why those earlier records matter. In Rausch’s list dated 5 August 1978, R 43 was Trichocereus poco and R 151 was Lobivia crassicaula. Rainer Wahl’s 1989 register gives different names for both. R 151 poses a further problem: the type citation in Rausch’s Lobivia 85 disagrees with the index in the same book and with Wahl’s list.

The directory dated 1978 and printed in 1981

The first ZAG ‘Echinopsidinae’ Informationsbrief, published in East Germany in May 1981, contains four pages headed Feldnummernverzeichnis Walter Rausch. Stand vom 5. August 1978. The entries run from 1 to 168, with several lettered suffixes. They are part of a much larger series, not a complete account of Rausch’s collections up to that date. The introduction calls them ‘WR-Nummern’, while the list itself prints bare numbers. Both R and WR have since been used on collection labels.

The list was dated August 1978 but published in May 1981. Neither date should be mistaken for the collecting date of every entry. An earlier booklet issued by the Gesellschaft Österreichischer Kakteenfreunde (GÖK) in Vienna in 1975 covered Rausch’s first six journeys, from 1962 to 1974, and numbers 1 to 705. That booklet is documented in subsequent specialist bibliographies.

The headings give useful geographical context, including Quebrada del Toro, Cachipampa-Cachi, Quebrada de Humahuaca and Famatina-Velasco. They are regional localities, not precise coordinates, and they cannot authenticate every later plant sold with the same number. Our field-number and provenance guide explains what a numbered collection can, and cannot, tell us about its cultivated descendants.

The seven entries originally labelled Trichocereus

Seven entries in this 1981-published extract use Trichocereus or the abbreviation Trichoc.. The names below reproduce the original printed identifications; the locations follow the regional headings.

Rausch no.1978 name as printedRegional heading1981 page
10Trichoc. pasacana (Web.)Salta, Quebrada del Toro, Argentina5
12Trichoc. smrzianus Bkbg.Salta, Cachipampa-Cachi, Argentina5
43Trichocereus poco Bkbg.Jujuy, Quebrada de Humahuaca, Argentina5
44Trichocerreus herzogii RauschSalta, Cafayate-Alemania, Argentina5
55Trichoc. vollianus Bkbg.Cochabamba, Cochabamba, Bolivia5
81Trichoc. camarguensis Card.Chuquisaca, Camargo-Culpina, Bolivia6
118Trichoc. candicans Br. & R.San Luis, Sierra de San Luis, Argentina7

The original prints R 44 as Trichocerreus herzogii, with an extra r in the genus name. It is a printing error, not a separate genus. Wahl’s later Lobivia treatment also records Lobivia grandiflora var. herzogii, this time as R 795 from Tafí del Valle, Tucumán. The shared epithet is no reason to confuse R 44 with R 795.

Two other entries lead directly to plants familiar from our nursery. R 118 is Trichocereus candicans from the Sierra de San Luis, and R 81 is T. camarguensis from Bolivia. Our candicans archive and camarguensis archive bring together material offered under those names, without implying that every plant has the corresponding Rausch provenance.

The Lobivia names behind the Trichocereus records

Looking only for Trichocereus in the directory would miss much of the story. Rausch used Lobivia for some plants other authors had placed in Trichocereus, Helianthocereus or Soehrensia. His huascha, formosa and grandiflora groups are particularly relevant. R 15 and R 33 also matter because names used for them have caused confusion elsewhere. The ten entries below are selected for that history; they are not the directory’s complete Lobivia content.

Rausch no.1978 name as printedRegional heading1981 page
15Lob. korethroides Werd.Salta, Cachipampa-Cachi5
33Lob. vatteri KrainzJujuy, Quebrada de Humahuaca5
122Lob. huascha (Web.) Marsh.La Rioja, Famatina-Velasco7
122aLob. huascha v. FamatinaLa Rioja, Famatina-Velasco7
122cLob. pecheretiana (Bkbg.)La Rioja, Famatina-Velasco7
128Lob. ingens (Br. & R.)La Rioja, Famatina-Velasco7
128aLob. formosa v. velascoensis Rausch n.n.La Rioja, Famatina-Velasco7
129Lob. rosarioana RauschLa Rioja, Famatina-Velasco7
151Lob. crassicaula Bkbg.Catamarca, Andalgalá-Hualfín8
153Lob. andalgalensis (Web.)Catamarca, Sierra Ancasti8

The 1978 list jumps from 122a to 122c. Wahl’s 1989 register includes 122b.

Rausch revises the plants, Wahl records the numbers

In Lobivia: Die tagblütige Echinopsidinae aus arealgeographischer Sicht, published in three parts from 1975, Rausch compared variation across geographical ranges and often interpreted familiar names within broader groups. He carried that approach further in Lobivia 85, drawing on more expeditions, cultivated plants and seed studies.

Rainer Wahl’s Lobivia 1989 provides the next dated set of identifications. Alongside corrections and translated diagnoses are numerical and geographical registers of Rausch’s collections, including records from his 1987 expedition. Wahl acknowledges help from Rausch and Gottfried Winkler, and follows the treatment developed in Lobivia 85.

The locations and elevations in the last column are from Wahl’s 1989 register, not the earlier four-page extract.

R number1978 identificationWahl 1989 identification1989 locality and elevation
15L. korethroidesL. formosa var. nivalisCachipampa, Salta; 3,800 m
33L. vatteri KrainzL. jajoiana var. nigrostomaMaimará, Jujuy; 2,500 m
43Trichocereus pocoL. formosa var. tarijensisHumahuaca, Jujuy; 3,800 m
122L. huaschaL. huaschaFamatina, La Rioja; 1,500-2,000 m
122aL. huascha v. FamatinaL. huascha var. callianthaCuesta Miranda, La Rioja; 3,000 m
122bNot printedL. huaschaFamatina, La Rioja; 1,500 m
122cL. pecheretianaNot listedNot given
128L. ingensL. formosa var. ingensAndalgalá; 2,500 m *
128aL. formosa v. velascoensis n.n.L. formosa var. velascoensis n. prov.Sierra de Velasco, La Rioja; 2,800 m
129L. rosarioanaL. formosa var. rosarioanaFamatina, La Rioja; 3,000 m
151L. crassicaulaL. grandiflora var. longispinaAgua de las Palomas, Catamarca; 2,000 m
151aNot printedL. grandiflora var. crassicaulisAndalgalá-Estancia, Catamarca; 1,800 m
151bNot printedL. grandifloraAndalgalá, Catamarca; 2,200 m
153L. andalgalensisL. huascha var. rubrifloraSierra Ancasti, Catamarca; 1,000 m

* Wahl places R 128 under La Rioja in the numerical register, but prints Andalgalá as its locality. Andalgalá is in Catamarca. The source’s geographical mismatch is retained here rather than silently corrected.

Wahl’s 1989 register concentrates on Lobivia; the absence of R 10, R 55 or R 81 from it does not mean the earlier Trichocereus records ceased to exist.

R 153 changed just as strikingly. The 1978 list gives Lobivia andalgalensis from Sierra Ancasti; Wahl’s 1989 entry calls it L. huascha var. rubriflora. Our andalgalensis archive retains the older name as a useful part of the cultivated record.

R 12, smrzianus and a field encounter with Kiesling

In December 1972 Roberto Kiesling travelled with Rausch through the Quebrada de Escoipe in Salta. They encountered large white-flowered plants which Kiesling called Trichocereus smirzianus. Beside them, Rausch pointed out plants of similar appearance but with smaller yellow flowers. Kiesling returned to examine them in flower. The distinction was not obvious from the stems alone. For comparison with the cultivated plants circulated under the former name, see our smrzianus archive.

Kiesling thought Backeberg’s original account of smrzianus might have brought together characters of both plants; that was his interpretation, not a verified reconstruction of the original material. He described the yellow-flowered plant as Lobivia walterii in 1976. The type was Kiesling & Ferrari 1109, collected in November 1975. That number must not be confused with Rausch’s R 12, printed as Trichoc. smrzianus in the 1978 directory. Kew currently accepts Echinopsis walteri.

Rausch subsequently placed the yellow-flowered plant under Lobivia huascha var. walteri. Wahl’s 1989 list gives R 709 for it, at Escoipe, Salta, 2,800 m. R 709a, immediately alongside it in the register, is L. haematantha var. viridis from Río Yacuchuya. A single added letter changes the record. We maintain cultivated material associated with R 709 in our walteri archive; the historical number describes a source collection, not a guarantee that every plant circulating under it is the same clone.

Cultivated Trichocereus walteri plant associated with Walter Rausch number R 709
Our cultivated Trichocereus walteri R 709 / WR 709 material.

R 43: from poco to tarijensis

R 43 was Trichocereus poco in the 1978 list, from Jujuy’s Quebrada de Humahuaca. In Lobivia 85, Rausch placed poco within his treatment of Lobivia formosa var. tarijensis. Wahl’s register then lists R 43 under that variety at Humahuaca, 3,800 m. The number stayed the same while Rausch’s interpretation of the plant moved.

An old label reading poco may preserve a perfectly sound historical identification; a later tarijensis label does not cancel it. Our tarijensis archive covers the wider group, while the dedicated poco archive is the better place to browse material sold under the older name. Our Trichocereus identification keys provide further comparisons. The name poco alone, however, is not proof of R 43 provenance.

Cultivated Trichocereus tarijensis var. poco cactus in the Freaky Cacti collection
Our cultivated Trichocereus tarijensis var. poco. This plant illustrates the traditional poco name; it is not presented as R 43 material.

R 122, 122a, 122b and 122c: four entries, not interchangeable labels

In the 1978 list, R 122 is Lobivia huascha, R 122a is L. huascha ‘v. Famatina’, and R 122c is L. pecheretiana. Wahl’s 1989 list retains L. huascha for R 122, places R 122a under var. calliantha at Cuesta de Miranda (3,000 m), and adds R 122b as L. huascha from Famatina (1,500 m). R 122c is not listed there. These four entries cannot be treated as one seed line, nor does the appearance of 122b in the later register show that it replaced 122c. Our huascha archive brings together material associated with this historically broad name.

The change to calliantha opens a separate taxonomic disagreement. Rausch distinguished Ritter’s high-elevation Trichocereus callianthus from the longer-branched plants with variable flower colours described by Kiesling as T. vatteri. Ritter argued for a closer connection. The differences between Ritter’s and Rausch’s interpretations survive in their own publications, even though later authors have used broader huascha concepts. For our plants, the original received name is worth retaining alongside any subsequent determination.

Our broader Trichocereus field-number reference also records the subsequent horticultural use of R 122 / WR 122 under Trichocereus vatteri. That received identity is not the identification printed beside 122 in the 1978 directory or Wahl’s 1989 Lobivia list. For the broader plants and crosses historically traded as vatteri, see the vatteri archive.

Cultivated Trichocereus vatteri labelled R 122 / WR 122 in the Freaky Cacti collection
Our cultivated Trichocereus vatteri material labelled R 122 / WR 122. Rausch’s earlier directory records R 122 as Lobivia huascha.

R 151: a name change and a contradiction in the original book

R 151 was Lobivia crassicaula Bkbg. under Andalgalá-Hualfín in 1978. In the index to Lobivia 85, Rausch assigns 151 to Lobivia grandiflora var. longispina and 151a to var. crassicaulis. Wahl follows this arrangement in 1989 and adds 151b under L. grandiflora. That would be a straightforward change of identification were it not for the wording of Rausch’s own description.

On printed p. 139 of Lobivia 85, the description of var. longispina says “Typus: Rausch 151 a”. But the alphabetical index in the same book puts 151 under longispina and 151a under crassicaulis. Wahl’s original 1989 printing independently gives Rausch 151 as the type of longispina on p. 11 and repeats that number in both registers.

One of these readings may be a printing error, but neither book establishes which. The distinction matters when tracing plants or seed circulated under either suffix.

The 1989 localities also distinguish the suffixes: 151 is Agua de las Palomas (2,000 m), 151a Andalgalá-Estancia (1,800 m), and 151b Andalgalá (2,200 m), all in Catamarca. Kew currently accepts Echinopsis crassicaulis and includes Rausch’s longispina and crassicaulis varieties in its synonymy. That modern treatment does not turn R 151, R 151a and R 151b into one field record. Our crassicaulis archive preserves the cultivated names under which related plants and crosses are known.

Two vatteri names, and a third unrelated number 15

R 33 in the 1978 directory is Lobivia vatteri Krainz, recorded in Jujuy. In Wahl’s 1989 list it appears as Lobivia jajoiana var. nigrostoma from Maimará. Kew treats Krainz’s name as a synonym of Echinopsis marsoneri. This plant is not Kiesling’s Trichocereus vatteri of La Rioja, which Kew instead includes under Echinopsis huascha subsp. huascha. The shared epithet honours Ernesto Vatter; it does not make the two names interchangeable. Our jajoiana archive provides a route to related cultivated and hybrid material, not an assertion that those plants belong to R 33.

Ernesto Vatter also used a number of his own: ‘Vatter No. 15’. In 1949 he described extensive clumps of day-flowering plants, in places covering around three square metres, with stems over two metres long. He reported white, yellow, orange, clay-coloured and red flowers, and published photographs of yellow- and red-flowered plants in Sukkulentenkunde. He discussed coloured Trichocereus candicans from the same general region separately.

Rausch placed Vatter No. 15 within his broad huascha concept. He also recalled seeing plants imported by Vatter and later speaking to him in Buenos Aires. The cultivated material had a life of its own: Karl Eckert’s account of Robert Gräser’s hybrid ‘Kaffee’ names a yellow-flowered Vatter No. 15 as the pollen parent. None of that makes a plant labelled ‘Vatter No. 15’ the same thing as Rausch’s R 15, nor does it establish that all plants traded under Vatter’s designation were identical clones.

Rausch’s R 15 was Lobivia korethroides in 1978 and L. formosa var. nivalis in Wahl’s 1989 register. The same four-page directory also contains a different Gymnocalycium vatteri at R 110. Collector, number and author all need to travel with an old cactus label. For the wider genus boundaries behind these names, our illustrated Trichocereus species guide gives the broader picture.

Provisional names and the trouble with old labels

The name velascoensis associated with R 128a remained provisional. Rausch printed Lobivia formosa var. velascoensis with ‘n.n.’ in 1978; in Lobivia 85 he again treated it provisionally and described the Sierra de Velasco plants without having seen their flowers. Wahl’s 1989 register adds an elevation of 2,800 m. A fuller locality entry does not turn a provisional name into a formally published one.

Occasionally a numbered gathering needed more than a change of name. Hans-Jürgen Wittau and Gottfried Winkler described an Aylostera gathering near Santa Victoria in Informationsbrief 23 (1996). Material collected in the same party proved to contain two species. The account follows Hoffmann’s H 1960/H 1960a, Rausch’s R 521a, subsequent cultivation and Rausch’s return collection R 784. It is a different cactus group, but a clear instance of a field identification being tested against living plants and further collecting.

Modern databases can be useful for finding a number, but the name they display may belong to a later treatment. The September 2026 Rare Cactus compilation gives R 43 as Echinopsis poco and R 44 as E. schickendantzii, where the 1978 directory prints Trichocereus poco and T. herzogii. Its R/WR records also include duplicated prefix variants, while the R 122 and R 151 groups are missing. For historical identifications, the dated lists remain indispensable.

On our labels we keep the collector’s code and suffix, the received name, the source or grower and any later determination as separate details. WR 122a should not quietly become WR 122b. Our guide to labelling cacti explains the practical side; our collector-code reference covers R and WR. For another well-documented series, see the Friedrich Ritter FR-number register. Those prefixes belong to different collectors, and the distinction is worth preserving.

References

  • Rausch, Walter. Lobivia: Die tagblütige Echinopsidinae aus arealgeographischer Sicht. Three-part work, 1975-1977 (bibliographic dates vary by part); especially vol. III, p. 172, for the historical treatment of Vatter No. 15.
  • Gesellschaft Österreichischer Kakteenfreunde (ed.). Verzeichnis der Sammelnummern Walter Rausch: Erste bis sechste Sammelreise 1962-1974. Vienna: GÖK, 1975. Cited in Informationsbrief 23 (1996), p. 41.
  • Rausch, Walter. “Feldnummernverzeichnis Walter Rausch. Stand vom 5. August 1978.” Informationsbrief 1, ZAG ‘Echinopsidinae’, May 1981, pp. 5-8. Original numbered directory and regional headings.
  • Rausch, Walter. Lobivia 85. Vienna: Rudolf Herzig, imprint 1985/86, published 1987. See the opening reminiscence for his own account of the journeys, plus pp. 44-53, 68-76, 139 and the alphabetical register, pp. 147-152. The longispina type-number wording on p. 139 disagrees with the index.
  • Papsch, Wolfgang. “Walter Rausch 15.11.1928-22.11.2022.” Kakteen und andere Sukkulenten 74(4) (2023), pp. 97-102. Biographical obituary.
  • Wahl, Rainer. Lobivia 1989. Limburg: Rainer Wahl, September 1989. See p. 11 for the longispina type citation; pp. 43-46 for corrections; pp. 47-56 and 57-69 for numerical and geographical field-number registers. The original printed 1989 edition gives R 151 for longispina, corroborating the number used in its own registers.
  • Kiesling, Roberto. “Una nueva especie de Lobivia (Cactaceae).” Hickenia 1(7) (December 1976), pp. 35-38. Original paper (PDF); field observations with Rausch in December 1972, and the description of Lobivia walterii, typified by Kiesling and Ferrari 1109.
  • Vatter, Ernesto. “Tagblühende Trichocereen: meine letzten Neufunde.” Sukkulentenkunde III (1949), pp. 51-54, including the photographs on p. 52.
  • Kiesling, Roberto. “Novedades en Trichocereus (Cactaceae).” Hickenia 1(6), 1976, pp. 29-34; “El género Trichocereus (Cactaceae), I: Las especies de la República Argentina.” Darwiniana 21 (1978), including pp. 315-316 for T. vatteri.
  • Ritter, Friedrich. Kakteen in Südamerika, vol. II (1980), especially the callianthus treatment and later comments on vatteri.
  • Wittau, Hans-Jürgen, and Gottfried Winkler. “Was ist eigentlich …? Weniger Bekanntes von Walter Rausch und anderen.” Informationsbrief 23, Freundeskreis Echinopseen, October 1996, pp. 36-39. Original issue (PDF).
  • Eckert, Karl. “Robert Gräsers Trichocereus-Hybride ‘Kaffee’.” Kakteen und andere Sukkulenten 51(8) (2000), pp. 218-219.
  • Kealer, B. The Cactus Field Number Database, data paper and downloadable CSV, version 1.5 (September 2026). Rare Cactus field-number database. Used here as a modern comparison, not as a replacement for Rausch’s historical sources.
  • Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. Plants of the World Online, current taxonomic treatments of Echinopsis crassicaulis, E. huascha subsp. huascha and E. marsoneri.