Trichocereus vs Echinopsis – An overview

Trichocereus and Echinopsis are closely related South American cactus genera whose names have been combined, separated and rearranged repeatedly. That much is straightforward. The untidy part is everything that follows.

Many familiar Trichocereus have formally published names in Echinopsis. Some have since acquired accepted combinations in Leucostele or other genera. Many genuine Echinopsis, meanwhile, were never Trichocereus at all. Some came through Lobivia, Pseudolobivia or other lineages; others belong to the old core concept of Echinopsis. There are also names which cannot simply be transferred from one genus to the other because the obvious combination already belongs to a different cactus.

Trichocereus bridgesii is the classic warning. It does not become Echinopsis bridgesii. The familiar Bolivian Torch belongs under Echinopsis lageniformis in the current Kew treatment, while Echinopsis bridgesii is a separate species. Botanical nomenclature is occasionally quite efficient at punishing assumptions.

Freaky Cacti therefore retains Trichocereus as a useful horticultural, historical and collector framework while recording important alternative combinations and current treatments. Our Trichocereus species overview deals with the individual species in greater detail. This page has a different job: explaining what Trichocereus, Echinopsis, Lobivia, Soehrensia and Leucostele actually mean in relation to one another, and why apparently contradictory names can all have a legitimate place in a serious cactus collection.

Current-taxonomy note: taxonomic acceptance on this page refers principally to the Kew Plants of the World Online / World Checklist backbone as consulted in September 2026. Other serious treatments differ, and historical or horticultural names are retained where they preserve information which a current accepted combination does not.


Jump to: the short answer · five different kinds of name · history of the two genera · can they be separated by appearance? · molecular evidence · current treatment · Echinopsis which were never Trichocereus · plants genuinely named in both genera · the bridgesii trap · Leucostele · Lobivia and Soehrensia · hybrids · ×Trichoechinopsis and “Trichopsis” · the validus problem · how we label plants · references.


Trichocereus vs Echinopsis: the short answer

SituationExampleWhat it means
The same lineage has published names in both generaTrichocereus pachanoi / Echinopsis pachanoiDifferent taxonomic treatments have placed the same species in different genera.
An Echinopsis was never a TrichocereusEchinopsis eyriesii, E. subdenudata, E. hertrichianaEchinopsis contains much more than former Trichocereus.
A traditional Trichocereus now has an accepted Leucostele nameT. terscheckii / E. terscheckii / Leucostele terscheckiiThe same lineage has been placed in at least three genera.
The obvious Echinopsis transfer is unavailableT. bridgesii → E. lageniformisEchinopsis bridgesii already denotes another species.
A traditional Lobivia sits within broad EchinopsisLobivia hertrichiana / Echinopsis hertrichianaBeing an Echinopsis does not imply any historical connection with Trichocereus.
A historical pedigree crosses traditional generaEchinopsis eyriesii × Trichocereus candicansThe parental names can remain useful even when a broad taxonomy would call both parents Echinopsis.
A horticultural label and a current botanical interpretation have divergedlarge cultivated plants labelled “Trichocereus validus”The inherited label may preserve a horticultural concept which cannot safely be equated with the taxon currently attached to the botanical name.

The common statement that “Trichocereus is now Echinopsis” is therefore only partly useful. It describes one broad taxonomic treatment. It does not mean that every Echinopsis was formerly a Trichocereus, that every traditional Trichocereus currently belongs in Echinopsis, or that old collection and breeding records should be rewritten retrospectively.


First separate five different things

A surprising amount of cactus-taxonomy confusion comes from using “name” to mean several different things at once.

ConceptQuestion it answersExample
NomenclatureWas this botanical name or combination actually published, and under what rules?Echinopsis pachanoi is a published combination based on the plant previously described as Trichocereus pachanoi.
TaxonomyWhich name does a particular author or database regard as accepted?A current authority may accept Echinopsis broadly while another recognises Trichocereus.
Horticultural usageWhat name identifies the plant usefully among growers?“Trichocereus pachanoi” remains overwhelmingly useful when discussing San Pedro material, cultivars and breeding lines.
ProvenanceWhat was this particular accession received or circulated as?A plant may have arrived labelled T. werdermannianus ‘Tafira Alta’ long before a later treatment called the species Leucostele werdermanniana.
PedigreeWhat names did the breeder use for the actual parents?An old Trichocereus × Echinopsis pedigree is a breeding record, not merely a taxonomy exercise.

These can all be accurate simultaneously. A synonym is not necessarily an erroneous name. A historically correct label does not become false merely because a taxonomist later moves the species. Conversely, the existence of an old label does not prove that the underlying identification was correct.

This distinction is especially important with field-numbered and source material. Our guide to cactus field numbers and provenance explains why collection data should be preserved separately from later taxonomic interpretation.


How Echinopsis and Trichocereus arrived here

Echinopsis is the older name

Echinopsis was established by Joseph Gerhard Zuccarini in the nineteenth century. The conventional bibliographic citation is to 1837; IPNI notes that the relevant publication may actually have been issued in 1838. Either way, Echinopsis considerably predates Trichocereus.

Echinopsis eyriesii was later selected as the lectotype of the genus. Under the current Kew species treatment that familiar old name sits within the synonymy of Echinopsis oxygona, but its nomenclatural importance does not disappear with that synonymisation.

The original concept of Echinopsis centred on relatively low, globose to short-cylindrical South American cacti with conspicuously large funnel-shaped flowers. It did not begin as a new name for columnar Trichocereus. Those plants entered the story later.

Berger’s Trichocereus began inside Cereus

Alwin Berger established Trichocereus in 1905 as a subgenus of Cereus. Albesiano and Kiesling record fourteen species in Berger’s original subgeneric treatment.

Vincenzo Riccobono raised it to generic rank in 1909. His new genus was initially much smaller than the sprawling horticultural concept later familiar to collectors: he included Trichocereus macrogonus and T. spachianus.

Britton and Rose substantially expanded Trichocereus in the second volume of The Cactaceae in 1920, recognising nineteen species and fixing Cereus macrogonus as the type of the genus. Their account is worth reading because the problem was already visible. They acknowledged that the flowers suggested a relationship with Echinopsis, but did not regard that as sufficient reason to unite the genera.

So the argument is not a recent consequence of DNA sequencing. Botanists were staring at essentially the same awkward boundary a century ago.

1974: the broad Echinopsis treatment

The date most often encountered in horticulture is 1974. It is usually abbreviated to “Friedrich and Rowley merged Trichocereus into Echinopsis”, although the publication history is slightly more exact than that shorthand suggests.

Heimo Friedrich published his treatment of the Echinopsidinae/Trichocereinae in volume 3(3) of the IOS Bulletin. Gordon Rowley’s adjacent paper, Reunion of the genus Echinopsis, supplied the nomenclatural work associated with bringing a series of previously separated genera back under a broad Echinopsis. Numerous former Trichocereus therefore acquired Echinopsis combinations.

The broad treatment was influential, but it did not make Trichocereus vanish from either botany or horticulture. Subsequent authors have variously accepted Trichocereus, submerged it, restricted it or divided portions of the old assemblage among other genera.


Can Trichocereus and Echinopsis be separated by appearance?

Often, at a glance. Reliably across every species, no.

The familiar horticultural shorthand is that Trichocereus are elongated, columnar, shrubby or tree-like cacti with very large flowers borne on long, hairy tubes, commonly white and frequently opening at night. Old core Echinopsis, by contrast, tend to be globose or short cylindrical, often offsetting, and famous for disproportionately large trumpet-shaped flowers.

Those tendencies are real enough to remain useful. Our cactus morphology guide explains the structures involved. They are not, however, a clean generic key.

Traditional Trichocereus includes small or comparatively compact plants such as T. crassicaulis; brilliantly coloured flowering species such as T. huascha, T. rowleyi, T. tarijensis and T. walteri; and plants whose stems arch, crawl, scramble or hang rather than behaving like respectable columns. T. arboricola, T. hahnianus, T. serpentinus and T. vasquezii are among the subjects of our guide to prostrate and pendulous Trichocereus.

The other side is no tidier. Traditional Echinopsis such as the eyriesii/oxygona alliance produce immense, long-tubed flowers, often opening in the evening or at night. The simplistic internet contrast of “day-flowering Echinopsis versus night-flowering Trichocereus” does not survive much time among actual plants.

Our cactus flower gallery shows some of this variation without asking a taxonomic key to do a job for which it was never designed.

Morphology still matters enormously. What failed was the expectation that one or two conspicuous characters – columnar versus globose, white versus coloured flowers, nocturnal versus diurnal anthesis – would necessarily reveal the evolutionary history of the whole alliance.


What molecular studies changed

The 2012 plastid study

Schlumpberger and Renner’s 2012 study was a major reason for caution about the very broad Echinopsis then in widespread use. They sampled 162 plants representing 144 taxa and analysed approximately 3,800 nucleotides of chloroplast DNA.

The resulting phylogeny did not recover broad Echinopsis as a simple monophyletic unit, nor did it support several of the older multi-species segregate genera as neatly monophyletic groups. Growth habit and pollination-associated characters appeared evolutionarily labile, with similar forms arising repeatedly.

That result fitted the practical problem rather well: columnar stems and particular flower syndromes can evolve more than once, so a classification constructed mainly from those characters may group together plants which resemble one another for reasons other than especially close common ancestry.

The 2025 nuclear phylogenomic study

The much larger study by de Vos and colleagues, published in 2025, used hundreds of nuclear genes rather than the much smaller chloroplast dataset available in 2012. It sampled 170 cactus species with broad representation across the family and produced a new phylogenomic backbone and classification.

Its result for the traditional Echinopsis alliance differed materially from the 2012 plastid tree. The lineages of broad Echinopsis, excluding Leucostele and Reicheocactus, fell within a well-supported monophyletic clade. The authors’ resulting classification uses Echinopsis broadly and places familiar generic names including Trichocereus, Lobivia and Soehrensia within it.

That does not mean “DNA proved the old lumpers right and the splitters wrong”. The studies used different genomes, different quantities of data, different taxon sampling and different analytical approaches. Rapid evolutionary radiations are particularly good at producing conflicting gene histories, which is one reason cactus classification has been stubbornly difficult.

There is an additional qualification particularly relevant here: Leucostele was not directly sampled in the 2025 phylogenomic dataset. The authors retained it in their classification but explicitly identify it among the unsampled lineages. The new study therefore provides a much stronger nuclear framework for much of Trichocereinae without magically settling every species and every generic boundary.

The whole group is very closely related

De Vos and colleagues also make a horticulturally familiar point in unusually useful language. Members of Trichocereinae are very closely related, and artificial hybrids between traditional genera are numerous; many are fertile and can be used in later generations. They suggest that the wider assemblage could conveniently be considered an “Echinopsis comparium”.

Anyone who has spent years crossing these plants may find the molecular literature arriving at that observation rather reassuring.

Crossability is still not, by itself, a definition of a genus. Plants in different recognised genera can hybridise. What the extraordinary fertility of this group tells us is that the boundaries drawn by older morphology-based genera separate lineages which remain biologically very close.


Where current taxonomy leaves the names

As of September 2026, Kew’s Plants of the World Online accepts Echinopsis as a genus and lists Trichocereus, Lobivia and Soehrensia among its generic synonyms. Kew separately accepts Leucostele.

This is an important current treatment, but it is not the only serious taxonomic treatment to have existed recently. Kew’s own record for Trichocereus documents earlier modern sources in which it was accepted separately. Taxonomy is an interpretation of biological relationships, not a referendum in which one database permanently confiscates every other name.

For that reason we retain distinct Trichocereus and Echinopsis catalogue routes. They are useful ways of finding and understanding cultivated material even where a current broad classification would place both beneath one generic heading.

A current accepted name is particularly useful when discussing present botanical taxonomy. A historical name may be more useful when reading Ritter, Backeberg, old nursery catalogues, collection labels or hybrid pedigrees. Good records allow us to have both.


Which Echinopsis were never Trichocereus?

This is the part most often lost when people say that “Echinopsis is the new name for Trichocereus”. It is not.

Echinopsis existed for decades before Trichocereus was erected, and broad Echinopsis has also absorbed or overlapped with lineages historically called Lobivia, Pseudolobivia, Acantholobivia and several other names. In the nomenclatural histories checked for the FC-relevant examples below, there is no published Trichocereus combination for the species concept in question.

FC-relevant plantRelevant naming historyWhy it matters here
Echinopsis eyriesiiAn old core Echinopsis name and historically the selected type species of the genus; current Kew treatment places it within E. oxygona.It was not produced by transferring a Trichocereus into Echinopsis.
Echinopsis oxygonaA classic accepted Echinopsis species closely associated with the old eyriesii concept.Again, genuine old Echinopsis, not renamed Trichocereus.
Echinopsis subdenudataPublished in Echinopsis; later combinations and interpretations connect it with the lobivioid side of the alliance. Current Kew treatment places it within E. ancistrophora.No Trichocereus history is needed to explain its presence in Echinopsis.
Echinopsis hertrichianaHistorically familiar as Lobivia hertrichiana and also transferred through other lobivioid generic treatments.A good example of an Echinopsis whose important alternative genus is Lobivia, not Trichocereus.
Echinopsis kermesinaA compact flowering Echinopsis name now placed by Kew within E. mamillosa.Another horticulturally useful Echinopsis with no reason to invent a Trichocereus history.
Echinopsis obrepandaIts nomenclatural history runs through Echinocactus, Pseudolobivia, Lobivia and Echinopsis.It illustrates how much of broad Echinopsis comes from lineages outside traditional Trichocereus.
Echinopsis densispinaStrongly associated with historical Lobivia/Hymenorebutia treatments.Again, broad Echinopsis does not mean former Trichocereus.
Lobivia winterianaCurrently placed within the Echinopsis backebergii complex.Its useful horticultural history is Lobivia–Echinopsis, not Trichocereus–Echinopsis.

This is why converting an entire collection from “Trichocereus” to “Echinopsis” and then assuming all plants under Echinopsis belong to one old horticultural group destroys information rather than improving it.


Which traditional Trichocereus have genuinely been named in Echinopsis?

Many of them. The important phrase is published combination. The table below does not claim that every Echinopsis combination is the currently accepted species name in September 2026. It records the nomenclatural bridge between the two genera and flags major later placements where they are especially relevant.

Traditional Trichocereus namePublished Echinopsis name or equivalent transferCurrent / useful note
Trichocereus andalgalensisEchinopsis andalgalensisPublished combination.
T. angelesiaeE. angelesiaePublished combination.
T. arboricolaE. arboricolaSoehrensia arboricola has also been published.
T. atacamensisE. atacamensisCurrent Kew genus placement: Leucostele.
T. bertramianusE. bertramianaPublished combination.
T. bolligerianusE. bolligerianaCurrent Kew name: Leucostele bolligeriana.
T. bridgesiiE. lageniformisNot E. bridgesii; explained separately below.
T. × cabreraeE. × cabreraeCurrent Kew treatment: ×Leia cabrerae.
T. camarguensisE. camarguensisPublished combination.
T. candicansE. candicansPublished combination; a useful coloured-flowering counterexample to simplistic generic keys.
T. caulescensE. caulescensPublished combination.
T. chalaensisE. chalaensisPublished combination.
T. chiloensisE. chiloensisCurrent Kew name: Leucostele chiloensis.
T. crassicaulisE. crassicaulisCompact growth and colourful flowers make it particularly interesting near the old Trichocereus/Lobivia boundary.
T. cuzcoensisE. cuzcoensisPublished combination.
T. deserticolusE. deserticolaCurrent Kew name for the species complex: Leucostele deserticola.
T. faundeziiE. faundeziiCurrent Kew name: Leucostele faundezii.
T. hahnianusE. hahnianaAlso involved in published Soehrensia/Harrisia treatments.
T. huaschaE. huaschaColourful-flowering, highly variable traditional Trichocereus.
T. knuthianusE. knuthianaPublished combination.
T. lamprochlorusE. lamprochloraPublished combination.
T. macrogonusE. macrogonaEspecially important because Cereus macrogonus is the nomenclatural type underlying Trichocereus.
T. nigripilisE. nigripilisCurrent Kew name: Leucostele nigripilis.
T. pachanoiE. pachanoiOne of the best-known genuinely dual usages.
T. peruvianusE. peruvianaCurrent Kew treatment places E. peruviana within E. macrogona.
T. purpureopilosusE. purpureopilosaPublished combination; later species-level interpretations differ.
T. quadratiumbonatusE. quadratiumbonataPublished combination.
T. rowleyiE. rowleyiCurrent Kew treatment associates the name with E. crassicaulis; T. grandiflorus is also important horticulturally.
T. schickendantziiE. schickendantziiSoehrensia schickendantzii is another published treatment.
T. schoeniiE. schoeniiCurrent Kew treatment places the name within E. pachanoi.
T. scopulicolaE. scopulicolaCurrent Kew treatment places the name within E. lageniformis.
T. serpentinusE. serpentinaSoehrensia serpentina has also been published.
T. skottsbergiiE. skottsbergiiCurrent Kew name: Leucostele skottsbergii.
T. smrzianusE. smrzianaPublished combination.
T. spachianusE. spachianaOne of the two species included when Riccobono raised Trichocereus to generic rank.
T. spinibarbisE. spinibarbisPublished combination.
T. strigosusE. strigosaPublished combination.
T. tacaquirensisE. tacaquirensisPublished combination.
T. taquimbalensisE. taquimbalensisPublished combination; species limits within the surrounding complex have varied.
T. tarijensisE. tarijensisPublished combination.
T. terscheckiiE. terscheckiiCurrent Kew name: Leucostele terscheckii.
T. thelegonoidesE. thelegonoidesPublished combination.
T. thelegonusE. thelegonaPublished combination.
T. tulhuayacensisE. tulhuayacensisPublished combination; current Kew treatment places the name within E. cuzcoensis.
T. tunariensisE. tunariensisCurrent Kew name: Leucostele tunariensis.
T. undulosusE. undulosaCurrent Kew name: Leucostele undulosa.
T. uyupampensisE. uyupampensisPublished combination.
T. vasqueziiE. vasqueziiSoehrensia vasquezii has also been published.
T. vatteriE. vatteriPublished combination.
T. vollianusE. vollianaPublished combination.
T. walteriE. walteriSmall, yellow-flowering traditional Trichocereus which again resists the usual stereotype.
T. werdermannianusE. werdermannianaCurrent Kew name: Leucostele werdermanniana.

This is why “both” is often the most accurate answer. Trichocereus pachanoi and Echinopsis pachanoi are not two different cacti merely because different genera appear on the labels. Our San Pedro cactus FAQ discusses that particular group and its accumulated names in more detail.


A useful exception: not every newer Trichocereus name passed through Echinopsis

There is a subtler category which is easy to miss when older synonym lists are copied mechanically.

Sofía Albesiano described the Chilean species now accepted as Leucostele pectinifera in her 2012 revision of Trichocereus. The nomenclatural record gives the original name as Trichocereus pectinifer Albesiano; the spelling pectiniferus is also widespread in horticultural and secondary sources.

The important point here is not the grammatical ending. This modern species name was established in Trichocereus and subsequently combined in Leucostele. We have not found a corresponding published Echinopsis combination for that same species in the authoritative nomenclatural sources checked for this article. An unrelated occurrence of the epithet pectinifera elsewhere in Echinopsis must not be mistaken for one.

It is therefore unsafe to generate “Echinopsis equivalents” algorithmically. Botanical names are not search-and-replace strings.


The bridgesii trap: Trichocereus bridgesii is not Echinopsis bridgesii

This deserves its own section because it is probably the most consequential naming error in everyday Trichocereus horticulture.

NameWhat it refers to
Trichocereus bridgesiiThe familiar Bolivian Torch lineage. Current Kew treatment places this name in the synonymy of Echinopsis lageniformis.
Echinopsis lageniformisThe current Kew-accepted Echinopsis name for the lineage traditionally called Trichocereus bridgesii.
Echinopsis bridgesiiA separately published and currently accepted species, also historically combined as Lobivia bridgesii. It is not the Bolivian Torch traditionally called Trichocereus bridgesii.

The reason is nomenclatural priority and homonymy rather than somebody deciding that “bridgesii” sounded insufficiently cactus-like. When the traditional Trichocereus lineage is treated in Echinopsis, the epithet bridgesii cannot simply be reused for it because Echinopsis bridgesii already belongs to another species.

The correct modern equivalence under this broad treatment is therefore:

Trichocereus bridgesii → Echinopsis lageniformis, not Echinopsis bridgesii.

This single example is a good reason never to bulk-edit botanical names from a synonym spreadsheet without checking the underlying nomenclature.


Where Leucostele fits

Leucostele is the most important third genus in any modern explanation of Trichocereus versus Echinopsis. It currently contains thirteen Kew-accepted species, most of which are deeply familiar to growers under Trichocereus names.

Our guide to Leucostele species covers them individually. The current accepted list is:

Current accepted LeucosteleImportant traditional names
Leucostele atacamensisTrichocereus atacamensis; Echinopsis atacamensis
L. bolligerianaTrichocereus bolligerianus; Echinopsis bolligeriana
L. chiloensisTrichocereus chiloensis; Echinopsis chiloensis
L. deserticolaTrichocereus deserticolus/deserticola; Echinopsis deserticola; related former fulvilanus material
L. faundeziiTrichocereus faundezii; Echinopsis faundezii
L. litoralisTrichocereus litoralis; T. chiloensis subsp. litoralis; Echinopsis litoralis
L. nigripilisTrichocereus nigripilis; Echinopsis nigripilis
L. pectiniferaTrichocereus pectinifer Albesiano; frequently rendered horticulturally as T. pectiniferus
L. skottsbergiiTrichocereus skottsbergii; Echinopsis skottsbergii
L. terscheckiiTrichocereus terscheckii; Echinopsis terscheckii
L. tunariensisTrichocereus tunariensis; Echinopsis tunariensis
L. undulosaTrichocereus undulosus; Echinopsis undulosa
L. werdermannianaTrichocereus werdermannianus; Echinopsis werdermanniana

Several are among the enormous high-Andean cacti discussed in our guide to giant Andean ‘Cardón’ Trichocereus. This is one reason Leucostele is particularly conspicuous to anyone accustomed to older collector terminology: it captures some very familiar heavyweight members of traditional Trichocereus.

It does not replace Trichocereus wholesale. T. pachanoi, T. peruvianus, T. bridgesii, T. scopulicola, T. candicans, T. huascha, T. spachianus and many other familiar traditional species are not among those thirteen accepted Leucostele.

Nor should the 2025 phylogenomic paper be cited as direct molecular proof for every current Leucostele placement. The genus was one of the lineages the authors were unable to sample directly. Their classification recognises it, but that is a different statement from saying every included species was genetically tested in that study.


Lobivia and Soehrensia: the other side of broad Echinopsis

Lobivia

Lobivia matters because it demonstrates more clearly than almost anything else that “Echinopsis” and “former Trichocereus” are not synonymous ideas.

Traditional Lobivia contains many compact Andean cacti with naturally colourful flowers. Numerous names have been transferred between Lobivia and Echinopsis, and current Kew generic treatment includes Lobivia within broad Echinopsis.

We nevertheless retain a Lobivia catalogue route because it remains extremely informative horticulturally. Lobivia rauschii, for example, tells a grower something useful about the sort of cactus and horticultural tradition involved which would be obscured by treating every historic generic name as disposable.

The visual case is fairly obvious in our Lobivia flower gallery.

Soehrensia

Soehrensia has likewise been treated both separately and within broader Echinopsis, and various traditional Trichocereus have received combinations in Soehrensia. Examples include lineages associated with T. schickendantzii, T. arboricola, T. serpentinus and T. vasquezii.

Our separate Soehrensia catalogue therefore remains useful for cultivated material and pedigrees even though the current Kew generic treatment places Soehrensia within Echinopsis. A plant such as Soehrensia uebelmanniana ‘RS1956’ carries a horticultural identity worth preserving independently of how broadly Echinopsis is circumscribed today.


A natural hybrid can change genus too: Trichocereus × cabrerae

Trichocereus × cabrerae provides an unusually tidy example of how several layers of taxonomy can accumulate around one plant.

The natural hybrid has been treated as Trichocereus × cabrerae and as Echinopsis × cabrerae. Under the current Kew treatment its parents are placed in different accepted genera and the hybrid is recognised as ×Leia cabrerae, corresponding to a cross between Leucostele terscheckii and Soehrensia strigosa.

Nothing biological happened to the hybrid while botanists moved the names around it. What changed was the taxonomic interpretation of its parental lineages, which in turn changed the nothogeneric name available for their hybrid.

It is a particularly good demonstration of why historical names should remain searchable. A reader encountering Trichocereus × cabrerae in older literature needs a route to the same plant, not a lecture about having searched for it incorrectly.


Trichocereus and Echinopsis in hybrid breeding

The practical relationship between these plants is perhaps clearest in a seed pod.

Traditional Trichocereus, Echinopsis, Lobivia and Soehrensia material has been crossed extensively in cultivation. Our guide to cacti known to cross with Trichocereus deals with compatibility and breeding in more detail.

The FC catalogue contains plenty of literal examples. Echinopsis eyriesii × Trichocereus candicans crosses an old core Echinopsis with traditional Trichocereus. Echinopsis kermesina × Trichocereus pachanoi does the same with San Pedro genetics. Our Echinopsis oxygona × Trichocereus angelesiae ‘RFPA 115.01’ F1 seed records the parents in the genera under which the actual breeding plants are maintained.

The boundaries become still less persuasive as reproductive barriers when Lobivia enters the pedigree. Lobivia rauschii × Trichocereus scopulicola ‘Poland’ and Lobivia jajoiana × Trichocereus crassicaulis preserve two traditional generic identities in breeding records which broad Echinopsis taxonomy could theoretically compress into one.

There are equally complex three-way histories: (Soehrensia hybrid) × (Trichocereus species × Echinopsis species) is a rather literal illustration of the problem.

Those names are not being retained because we imagine the plants occupy distant evolutionary worlds. Quite the opposite: their ease of hybridisation reflects how closely related they are. We retain the generic wording because it identifies the actual horticultural lines and parents used.

Historical hybrid breeding

This matters especially when dealing with old cultivars. Harry Johnson’s Paramount breeding programme belongs to a period when Echinopsis, Lobivia and Trichocereus had established horticultural meanings which should not be replaced retrospectively every time generic boundaries change. Our reference to Harry Johnson’s Paramount hybrids therefore retains the historical generic framework while distinguishing what is documented from later horticultural repetition.

Robert Schick developed that ornamental tradition much further. Our Robert Schick Echinopsis hybrid reference records his named introductions, and our Schick hybrid flower gallery shows many of the cultivars represented in our collection.

We continue crossing material across the same traditional boundaries ourselves. The Freaky Cacti hybrid breeding record documents our own crosses, while newer seed batches include combinations such as Echinopsis hybrid ‘Infinity’ × yellow-flowered Trichocereus huascha.

Rewriting every one of those pedigrees into whichever generic arrangement is current in a particular year would make the records less informative, not more scientific.


×Trichoechinopsis and “Trichopsis” are not quite the same thing

There is a formal botanical name for hybrids between the traditional genera Trichocereus and Echinopsis: ×Trichoechinopsis.

Curt Backeberg published the nothogenus ×Trichoechinopsis in Die Cactaceae in 1959 for hybrids of Trichocereus × Echinopsis. It records a taxonomic framework in which those parents were treated as members of separate genera.

If both parents are instead placed within broad Echinopsis, the same biological plant no longer requires an intergeneric nothogenus. This is one of the slightly comic consequences of changing generic limits around plants which continue breeding regardless.

“Trichopsis” also appears in horticulture, but should not automatically be treated as the formal equivalent of ×Trichoechinopsis. It can occur as shorthand in received pedigrees, and it can be part of an actual cultivar or collection label. Those are different uses.

For example, (Trichocereus thelegonus × Echinopsis eyriesii var. grandiflora) ‘Theleflora’ is a genuine traditional cross-genus pedigree. Material involving ‘Thelesina’ × Echinopsis oxygona f. variegata preserves “Trichopsis” in the horticultural identity inherited with the parent. Separately again, Trichocereus hybrid ‘Trichopsis’ (Sacred Succulents) actually carries ‘Trichopsis’ as a cultivar-style name.

Flattening all three uses into one supposed formal genus would create a new error while attempting to tidy an old one.


The Trichocereus validus problem

Trichocereus validus illustrates a different problem: a botanical name can acquire a horticultural meaning which no longer maps neatly onto the taxon attached to the name by modern nomenclatural work.

In specialist cultivation, “T. validus” has long been used for large, robust, strongly spined columnar plants resembling the general terscheckii–werdermannianus sort of cactus. Plants under that label occur in old collections and have been propagated and distributed widely.

The botanical name Trichocereus validus (Monv.) Backeb., however, is currently placed by Kew in the synonymy of Acanthocalycium rhodotrichum subsp. rhodotrichum. That interpretation plainly should not be applied blindly to every giant cultivated column carrying a “validus” label.

Our Trichocereus validus ‘Condy’ material is therefore a good example of why inherited horticultural identity and independently verified botanical identity must remain distinguishable.

Where a cultivated accession has been received as “validus”, preserving that record is useful. Recasting it confidently as an Acanthocalycium solely because a database attaches the botanical name T. validus to that taxon would substitute nomenclatural neatness for evidence about the actual plant.


Synonym does not mean invalid, fictitious or useless

The word “synonym” causes unnecessary trouble in horticulture because it is often treated as a polite botanical term for “wrong”. That is not what it means.

A botanical synonym may be a perfectly validly published name which a particular taxonomic treatment does not choose as its accepted name. Another treatment may circumscribe the taxa differently and accept it. A historical synonym may also remain the name under which a cultivar, field collection, breeder record or body of specialist literature is overwhelmingly known.

The generic name Trichocereus is itself a good example. It was formally established and has been accepted by major cactus workers and modern treatments. Current Kew taxonomy places it in the synonymy of Echinopsis. That makes it a taxonomic synonym under that treatment; it does not turn a century of Trichocereus literature into spelling mistakes.

Likewise, an old combination is not necessarily the name we would use in a modern flora, but it can be exactly the name required to understand an old pedigree or accession label.


How we use the names at Freaky Cacti

We do not try to make every label on the site imitate one taxonomic database. The catalogue is simultaneously a nursery catalogue, living collection, breeding record and provenance archive. Those functions sometimes require more information than one currently accepted binomial can carry.

Our normal working principles are:

  • Preserve received identity. If material came to us under a documented species, locality, field number, cultivar or breeder label, later taxonomy is recorded without pretending the original label never existed.
  • Use current taxonomy where it clarifies rather than erases. A plant can be described as Trichocereus terscheckii in the collection while its reference material explains that current Kew treatment accepts Leucostele terscheckii.
  • Do not invent simple one-for-one synonyms. Trichocereus bridgesii is not silently converted to Echinopsis bridgesii, and new combinations are not manufactured where none was published.
  • Do not rewrite historical pedigrees. If a breeder recorded Lobivia, Echinopsis or Trichocereus as a parent, that wording remains part of the breeding history unless there is evidence that the original identification itself was wrong.
  • Keep uncertain identities uncertain. A horticultural name such as “validus” is not promoted into a verified modern taxon merely because the same word occurs in a database.
  • Make alternative names searchable. Synonyms are useful chiefly when they help a reader connect literature, labels and plants rather than forcing them to guess which taxonomic era a page was written in.

For a collection plant, something as simple as the following can carry substantially more information than repeatedly replacing its name:

Collection identityTrichocereus werdermannianus ‘Tafira Alta’
Published Echinopsis combinationEchinopsis werdermanniana
Current Kew placementLeucostele werdermanniana
Horticultural identity retained?Yes, where it identifies the actual accession and history of the plant.

The taxonomic note can be updated again in future. The original provenance, once discarded, is rather less cooperative.


So which genus is “correct”?

For a current taxonomic discussion following the September 2026 Kew backbone, broad Echinopsis is accepted and Trichocereus is treated as a synonym; thirteen familiar former or traditional Trichocereus species sit in the separately accepted genus Leucostele.

For historical literature, breeder records, nursery history, field collections and much specialist horticulture, Trichocereus remains both meaningful and useful.

For some individual plants the answer is more specific still. A traditional Trichocereus may now be an accepted Leucostele; a traditional Lobivia may be an accepted Echinopsis; and Trichocereus bridgesii becomes Echinopsis lageniformis rather than the deceptively obvious Echinopsis bridgesii.

We therefore prefer a more useful question: which name is being used, under which treatment, and what information would be lost by replacing it?

That approach leaves room for taxonomy to improve without requiring a nursery to develop collective amnesia every time a cactus changes genus.


Selected references and further reading

Berger, A. (1905). Cereus subgen. Trichocereus, in the systematic revision of Cereus published in the Annual Report of the Missouri Botanical Garden, 16.

Riccobono, V. (1909). Establishment of Trichocereus at generic rank. Bollettino delle Reale Orto Botanico di Palermo, 8.

Britton, N. L. & Rose, J. N. (1920). The Cactaceae, Volume II. Carnegie Institution of Washington. Their account expanded Trichocereus and designated Cereus macrogonus as the type.

Friedrich, H. (1974). Zur Taxonomie und Phylogenie der Echinopsidinae (Trichocereinae). IOS Bulletin 3(3): 79–93.

Rowley, G. D. (1974). Reunion of the genus Echinopsis. IOS Bulletin 3(3): 93–99.

Albesiano, S. & Kiesling, R. (2012). Identity and neotypification of Cereus macrogonus, the type species of the genus Trichocereus (Cactaceae). Haseltonia 17: 24–34.

Albesiano, S. (2012). A new taxonomic treatment of the genus Trichocereus (Cactaceae) in Chile. Haseltonia 18: 116–139.

Schlumpberger, B. O. & Renner, S. S. (2012). Molecular phylogenetics of Echinopsis and related genera: polyphyly at all levels and convergent evolution of pollination modes and growth forms. American Journal of Botany 99(8): 1335–1349.

de Vos, J. M., Eggli, U., Nyffeler, R., Larridon, I., McGinnie, C., Epitawalage, N., Maurin, O., Forest, F. & Baker, W. J. (2025). Phylogenomics and classification of Cactaceae based on hundreds of nuclear genes. Plant Systematics and Evolution 311: 28. DOI: 10.1007/s00606-025-01948-z.

International Plant Names Index (IPNI). Used for nomenclatural publication data, authorship and original combinations.

Plants of the World Online / World Checklist of Vascular Plants, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew. Used as the principal current taxonomic backbone for accepted names and synonymy on this page, consulted September 2026.

For printed specialist material extending beyond this article, see our recommended Trichocereus books and references.